(Note: This analysis is taken from a letter that dates back to the mid-1990s and is included to show that the use of Magnetic Fuel Conditioners are not a recent development, but have been performing and saving money for a long time. The dollar calculations do not reflect today’s prices for fuel or filter elements.)
This cost savings analysis was prepared in cooperation with Master Chief Hill of the US Coast Guard Maintenance & Logistics Command using data from the 82' Cutter Pt. Chico, and 110' Cutters Anacapa and Long Island over a period of two years when the (formerly ALGAE-X) Magnetic Fuel Conditioner performance was monitored and evaluated.
Installation of the AXI Magnetic Fuel Conditioner (formerly ALGAE-X) units in Diesel Engine applications results in significant savings in personnel and engine maintenance costs, reduced downtime, periodic tank cleaning, toxic biocide additives, fuel consumption, and filter cartridge replacements. Not considering any additional benefits resulting from better fuel economy, which may be substantial, nor calculating savings from reduced downtime, the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner units have proven to pay for themselves in approximately 2 to 4 months!!
The Cutter Long Island reports that filter changes were required at 300 hours, or less. After installing the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner units the interval has increased to SOP of 400 hours, and the elements appear lean when changed, therefore could be run for additional hours. (Filter change intervals in systems with clean, bug free fuel can exceed 1,000 hours.)
If the filters cost $15 each and are replaced every 300 hours on 4 engines, or 12.5 24 hour run days, the cost per filter change is $60. If this represents 3 weeks of operations it requires approx. 17 changes per year at a cost of $1020.
With the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner the cost of filters replacement for this vessel will be at least 1/3 less, approx. $683. Savings on filter elements annually: $337.
Buildup of sludge/organic debris in fuel tanks ultimately requires having the tanks cleaned. Methods vary from emptying the tank and physically entering it to remove the sludge, to the use of a filtration/re-circulation system to "polish the fuel". The costs to perform this task include personnel, time and money. Typical rates for tank cleaning are approx. $.25 to $1 dollar per gallon of tank capacity.
An 82' Cutter with two 2,000 gallon tanks may cost $1,000-4,000 to clean every year or two. Methods vary from emptying the tank and physically entering it to remove the sludge, to the use of a filtration/re-circulation system to "polish the fuel". The costs to perform this task include personnel, time and money. Typical rates for tank cleaning are approx. $.25 to $1 dollar per gallon of tank capacity.
An 82' Cutter with two 2,000 gallon tanks may cost $1,000-4,000 to clean every year or two. Reduction in the amount of sludge buildup in tanks is a key benefit of the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner units. Working vessels have reported that tanks were totally free of sludge on inspection. Reducing Tank Cleaning by only 50% will save $500-2,000 annually.
The cost of biocides is $.005-.01 per gallon of fuel. Eliminating the need for this additive on a vessel using 2,000 gallons of fuel per week will save $500-1,000 annually. Elimination of storage facilities, hazardous disposal fees, and risks to personnel who are required to use these toxic items are important added benefits.
Calculating the cost of downtime for the Coast guard is different from that for a commercial vessel. Obviously, income is not generated from operations, however unavailability of one boat places added duty on others, and some missions simply are not accomplished. The Magnetic Fuel Conditioner will significantly increase unit readiness and reliability.
The consequences of bacterial contamination and fuel breakdown are not restricted to the quality of fuel. The formation of acid waste products also cause pitting and corrosion to injectors and pumps, as well as iron and aluminum oxides in fuel tanks, which become part of the fuel mix and contribute to engine wear and incomplete combustion. (SMOKE)
Injectors for mid sized engines can cost $100-175. If their duty cycle is 5,000 hours (approx. 1 year), injector replacement for a 12 cycle Engine will cost $1,200-2,100 annually. With the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner units controlling the effects of microbial contamination and, therefore, the production of acid and sludge in the fuel system, injectors and pumps should last 10,000 hours or more. This saves $600-1,050 per engine per year.
Providing Optimal fuel Quality results in Peak Engine Performance, which typically reduces fuel consumption and harmful emissions. A large portion of the stack emissions is attributable to non-combusted fuel. Many of the Magnetic Fuel Conditioner installations report reduced smoke, indicating that the fuel is burning more efficiently.
Most of these reports are anecdotal, and do not quantify the effects. However, a test with the Los Angeles County School District provided some interesting numbers, as has other dyno testing that showed total elimination of opacity. Other factors to consider are e.g. RPM's, load, sea conditions, etc.
The installation of the Magnetic Fuel Conditioners on the 12 cylinder main engines, and on the Gensets of an 82’ or 110’ Cutter would realize the follwoing estimated annual savings. These figures do not reflect the obvious savings in Fuel.